Discover The Best Restaurants on Anna Maria Island

This post may contain affiliate links. That means if you click and buy, we may make a commission at no cost to you. Please see my full disclosure policy for more details.

Discover the Best Restaurants on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island (AMI), a serene barrier island on Florida’s Gulf Coast, is a haven for those seeking sun, sand, and unforgettable culinary experiences. The island’s dining scene is as vibrant and diverse as its sunsets, offering everything from fresh seafood to international cuisine. Whether you’re a local or a visitor renting one of our Golf Cart Rentals with AMI Rentals, your culinary journey on the island promises to be a delightful adventure. From upscale dining to casual beachside cafes, here’s a guide to the best restaurants on Anna Maria Island that you absolutely must try featuring top spots like the Waterfront, Beach Bistro, Chateau Anna Maria Island, Blue Marlin, Bridge Tender Inn, SALT Bar & Table, Los Chiludos, Le Creperie Holmes Beach, Minnie’s Beach Cafe, Pizza Social, Fifty Three Fifty The Pour House, and Hurricane Hanks. 

1. The Waterfront Restaurant

Located at 111 South Bay Boulevard, The Waterfront Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone looking to enjoy fine dining with a view. This elegant eatery offers an impressive menu that focuses on locally sourced ingredients and fresh seafood. The restaurant’s atmosphere is both relaxed and sophisticated, with indoor and outdoor seating options that provide stunning views of the Tampa Bay.

Menu Highlights:
  • Appetizers: Start your meal with their famous Tuna Sashimi or the Crab Cakes, which are a crowd favorite.
  • Entrees: For the main course, the Grouper is a standout, often prepared with a delicious citrus beurre blanc. Meat lovers will appreciate the Ribeye Steak, cooked to perfection.
  • Desserts: Don’t miss out on the Key Lime Pie, a quintessential Floridian dessert.

The Waterfront is perfect for a romantic dinner or a special celebration, thanks to its impeccable service and beautiful setting.

2. Beach Bistro

Nestled at 6600 Gulf Drive, Beach Bistro is an award-winning restaurant that promises an extraordinary dining experience. Known for its fine dining and impeccable service, Beach Bistro has been delighting patrons for over three decades.

Menu Highlights:
  • Appetizers: The Lobster Bisque is a luxurious starter that sets the tone for an exceptional meal.
  • Entrees: The “Domestic Lamb” and the “Bouillabaisse” are highly recommended. The lamb is tender and flavorful, while the Bouillabaisse is a hearty seafood stew that’s both comforting and sophisticated.
  • Desserts: Their “Chocolate Truffle Terrine” is the perfect end to a gourmet meal.

Beach Bistro’s beachfront location and intimate atmosphere make it a top choice for those looking to enjoy a luxurious dining experience.

3. Chateau Anna Maria Island

Situated at 5325 Marina Drive, Chateau Anna Maria Island brings a touch of French elegance to the island’s dining scene. This charming restaurant offers a delightful mix of French and Mediterranean cuisine.

Menu Highlights:
  • Appetizers: The Escargots de Bourgogne and the Duck Confit Salad are excellent choices to start your meal.
  • Entrees: The Coq au Vin and the Bouillabaisse are standout dishes that showcase the chef’s expertise in French cooking.
  • Desserts: Finish with a classic Crème Brûlée or the Tarte Tatin for a sweet conclusion.

Chateau Anna Maria Island is perfect for those seeking a refined dining experience with a European flair.

4. Blue Marlin

Located at 121 Bridge Street, Blue Marlin is known for its fresh, locally sourced seafood and relaxed atmosphere. This charming restaurant is housed in a historic 1920s cottage, adding to its unique appeal.

Menu Highlights:
  • Appetizers: The Lobster Mac & Cheese is a rich and indulgent starter.
  • Entrees: The Blackened Grouper and Shrimp & Grits are highly recommended. Both dishes highlight the restaurant’s commitment to fresh, flavorful ingredients.
  • Desserts: The Key Lime Pie here is a local favorite.

Blue Marlin offers a cozy, laid-back dining experience that’s perfect for enjoying a taste of the sea.

5. Bridge Tender Inn

At 135 Bridge Street, the Bridge Tender Inn is a beloved spot known for its casual vibe and waterfront views. This restaurant and bar offer a diverse menu that includes seafood, burgers, and more.

Menu Highlights:
  • Appetizers: The Coconut Shrimp and Conch Fritters are great choices to start your meal.
  • Entrees: The Fish Tacos and Grouper Sandwich are popular options. Both are packed with flavor and perfect for a casual meal.
  • Desserts: Try the Chocolate Cake or the Ice Cream Sandwich for a sweet treat.

The Bridge Tender Inn’s relaxed atmosphere and live music make it a great spot for a laid-back evening with friends and family.

6. SALT Bar & Table

SALT Bar & Table, located at 5306 Holmes Boulevard, is a contemporary restaurant that focuses on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. With a modern, stylish interior and a creative menu, it’s a great spot for food enthusiasts.

Menu Highlights:
  • Appetizers: The Tuna Tartare and Roasted Beet Salad are both excellent starters.
  • Entrees: The Pan-Seared Scallops and Braised Short Rib are standout dishes that showcase the chef’s skill and creativity.
  • Desserts: The Chocolate Lava Cake is a must-try for chocolate lovers.

SALT Bar & Table is perfect for those looking to enjoy innovative dishes in a chic setting.

7. Los Chiludos

For those craving Mexican cuisine, Los Chiludos at 3232 East Bay Drive is the place to go. This vibrant restaurant offers a wide range of authentic Mexican dishes that are sure to satisfy.

Menu Highlights:
  • Appetizers: Start with the Guacamole and Queso Fundido, both made fresh to order.
  • Entrees: The Tacos al Pastor and Enchiladas are highly recommended. Both dishes are flavorful and well-prepared.
  • Desserts: The Churros are a sweet and satisfying way to end your meal.

Los Chiludos offers a lively atmosphere and delicious Mexican cuisine, making it a great spot for a fun night out.

8. Le Creperie Holmes Beach

Le Creperie Holmes Beach, located at 127 Bridge Street, brings a taste of France to Anna Maria Island. This charming café specializes in both sweet and savory crepes, making it a popular spot for breakfast and brunch.

Menu Highlights:
  • Savory Crepes: The Ham & Cheese Crepe and the Smoked Salmon Crepe are both delicious options.
  • Sweet Crepes: For a sweet treat, try the Nutella & Banana Crepe or the Classic Lemon & Sugar Crepe.
  • Beverages: Pair your crepe with a freshly brewed coffee or a refreshing mimosa.

Le Creperie Holmes Beach offers a cozy, casual dining experience that’s perfect for starting your day.

9. Minnie’s Beach Cafe

Located at 5360 Gulf Drive, Minnie’s Beach Cafe is a beloved local diner known for its hearty breakfasts and friendly service. This quaint eatery is a great spot to enjoy a classic American breakfast or lunch.

Menu Highlights:
  • Breakfast: The Pancakes and Omelets are both popular choices. The portions are generous, and the ingredients are fresh.
  • Lunch: The Burgers and Sandwiches are well-loved by regulars. The Tuna Melt is particularly recommended.
  • Desserts: Finish with a slice of their homemade pie for a sweet treat.

Minnie’s Beach Cafe offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere and delicious comfort food that will make you feel right at home.

10. Pizza Social

For those craving pizza, Pizza Social at 308 Pine Avenue is the go-to spot on Anna Maria Island. This casual pizzeria offers a variety of creative and classic pizza options, all made with fresh, high-quality ingredients.

Menu Highlights:
  • Pizzas: The Margherita and the Pepperoni pizzas are always a hit. For something different, try the BBQ Chicken or the Veggie Delight.
  • Appetizers: The Garlic Knots and Caprese Salad are perfect for sharing.
  • Desserts: The Nutella Pizza is a fun and delicious way to end your meal.

Pizza Social’s relaxed vibe and tasty pizzas make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

11. Fifty Three Fifty The Pour House

Located at 5350 Gulf Drive, Fifty Three Fifty The Pour House is a trendy spot known for its craft beers and delicious pub fare. With a wide selection of drinks and a menu that goes beyond typical bar food, it’s a great place to unwind.

Menu Highlights:
  • Appetizers: The Pretzel Bites and Buffalo Wings are perfect for sharing.
  • Entrees: The Burgers and Fish & Chips are highly recommended. Both are flavorful and satisfying.
  • Drinks: With a rotating selection of craft beers and creative cocktails, there’s always something new to try.

Fifty Three Fifty The Pour House is perfect for a casual night out with friends, offering great food and drinks in a lively atmosphere.

12. Hurricane Hanks

At 5346 Gulf Drive, Hurricane Hanks is a laid-back bar and grill that’s known for its friendly service and delicious food. This popular spot is a great place to enjoy a meal and catch a game on TV.

Menu Highlights:
  • Appetizers: The Buffalo Shrimp and Nachos are great for sharing.
  • Entrees: The Grouper Sandwich and Fish Tacos are must-tries. Both dishes are fresh and flavorful.
  • Desserts: The Brownie Sundae is a decadent way to end your meal.

Hurricane Hanks offers a fun, relaxed atmosphere and a menu that’s sure to please everyone.

Conclusion
Anna Maria Island’s culinary scene is as diverse as it is delicious. Whether you’re in the mood for fine dining or a casual bite, these restaurants offer something for every palate. Make your stay with AMI Rentals even more memorable by exploring these top dining spots on the island. Bon appétit, we hope you enjoy the best restaurants on Anna Maria Island!

Best Restaurants on Anna Maria Island

Picture of AMI Rentals

AMI Rentals

Locally owned and operated cart rentals on Anna Maria Island, Florida.

Welcome to the culinary paradise of Anna Maria Island! Nestled on Florida's Gulf Coast, this charming island offers a delightful mix of dining experiences, from casual beachside eateries to elegant fine dining establishments. Whether you're craving fresh seafood, classic American fare, or international cuisine, Anna Maria Island has something to satisfy every palate. Here are some of the top restaurants you won't want to miss.

Share:

Related Posts

Best Restaurants on Anna Maria Island

Discover The Best Restaurants on Anna Maria Island

Welcome to the culinary paradise of Anna Maria Island! Nestled on Florida’s Gulf Coast, this charming island offers a delightful mix of dining experiences, from casual beachside eateries to elegant fine dining establishments. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, classic American fare, or international cuisine, Anna Maria Island has something to satisfy every palate. Here are some of the top restaurants you won’t want to miss.

Read More »
Golf cart parking on Anna Maria Island

Convenience Meets Luxury: Designated Golf Cart Parking on Anna Maria Island

AMI Rentals is excited to introduce designated golf cart parking on Anna Maria Island. We understand that while renting a golf cart is a popular choice for exploring the island, finding suitable parking can sometimes be a hassle. That’s why we’ve taken the initiative to provide a list of designated parking areas on Anna Maria Island for our valued customers.

Read More »
Anna Maria Island Coffee Shops

Anna Maria Island Coffee Shops

With its quaint coffee shops, you can start your day with a perfectly brewed cup of joe while taking in the island’s beauty. Let’s embark on a caffeinated journey through some Anna Maria Island’s best coffee shops.

Read More »