Your Guide to Food Delivery on Anna Maria Island with IslandEats AMI

Anna Maria Island is renowned for its serene beaches, quaint shops, and relaxing vibes. But after a day of exploring this Gulf Coast paradise, there’s nothing better than enjoying a delicious meal from the comfort of your vacation rental. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh seafood, mouth-watering pizza, or even a gourmet donut, IslandEats AMI has partnered with some of the best local restaurants to deliver directly to your doorstep.

At AMI Rentals, we’re all about enhancing your stay on Anna Maria Island. That’s why we’re excited to spotlight IslandEats AMI, your go-to service for food delivery on the island. IslandEats AMI partners with an impressive list of local restaurants to bring you everything from gourmet cuisine to casual bites without leaving the comfort of your rental. Below, we dive into some of the fantastic eateries available through this service.

Why Choose IslandEats AMI?

First things first—what makes IslandEats AMI stand out? For starters, this service is hyper-local, meaning they know Anna Maria Island inside and out. They’ve built strong relationships with beloved local spots, ensuring your food is fresh and delivered promptly. Whether you’re staying in Bradenton Beach, Holmes Beach, or Anna Maria, IslandEats AMI provides island-wide delivery with a focus on efficiency and customer satisfaction.

Another perk is the variety of cuisine. From BBQ to gourmet pizza, and from fish tacos to Italian delicacies, there’s something for every craving. Let’s explore some of the top restaurants available through IslandEats AMI.

Featured Restaurants

1. Smoqe House

If you’re a fan of smoky, savory BBQ, then Smoqe House should be your first pick. Specializing in smoked meats like brisket, pulled pork, and ribs, Smoqe House combines bold flavors with classic southern comfort. Their extensive menu includes a variety of sandwiches, sides, and combo platters, perfect for satisfying your BBQ cravings.

2. Pizza Social

For pizza lovers, Pizza Social delivers hand-tossed artisan pizzas made with fresh, local ingredients. Whether you prefer a classic Margherita, a veggie-loaded pie, or a unique specialty pizza, Pizza Social has something to suit your taste buds. Don’t forget to add a side of their homemade garlic knots or a fresh salad to complete your order.

3. Poppo’s Taqueria

Craving something south of the border? Poppo’s Taqueria offers delicious, build-your-own-style Mexican cuisine. From burritos and tacos to rice bowls and quesadillas, everything is made-to-order with locally sourced ingredients. Try their popular Carnitas Tacos with a side of chips and guacamole for a satisfying meal that hits the spot.

4. Pizzano’s Pizza & Grinderz

For those who like their pizza with an extra layer of flair, Pizzano’s Pizza & Grinderz offers unique toppings and a hearty crust. Along with their creative pizzas, they also offer grinders, a type of hot sandwich loaded with meat, cheese, and fresh veggies. It’s comfort food at its finest!

5. Freckled Fin Irish Pub

Looking for some pub-style comfort food? The Freckled Fin is an Irish-American pub that serves up a fun mix of hearty dishes and island vibes. From burgers and fish & chips to shepherd’s pie and chicken wings, you’ll find something here to satisfy those cravings for good, hearty food.

6. Harry’s Grill

A classic among locals and visitors alike, Harry’s Grill is known for its relaxed vibe and diverse menu. You can choose from fresh seafood, mouthwatering burgers, and savory appetizers like crab cakes and fried green tomatoes. Harry’s is the kind of place that feels like home, even if you’re just visiting.

7. Kiwi Style Fish & Chips

If you’re in the mood for fish and chips with a twist, Kiwi Style Fish & Chips brings the flavors of New Zealand to Anna Maria Island. Their lightly battered fish is cooked to perfection, crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. Paired with a side of hand-cut fries, it’s a must-try for seafood lovers.

8. Los Chiludos

For authentic Mexican cuisine, Los Chiludos is your go-to. Their extensive menu features everything from tacos and enchiladas to burritos and fajitas. The flavors are rich and satisfying, offering a taste of traditional Mexican cooking right here on Anna Maria Island.

9. The Feast

As the name suggests, The Feast is all about indulgence. This upscale yet relaxed restaurant offers a wide range of dishes, including fresh seafood, gourmet pizzas, and mouth-watering steaks. Their commitment to using high-quality ingredients shines through in every bite, making it a great option for a special night in.

10. Island Donut Company

Whether you’re looking for a breakfast treat or a sweet snack, Island Donut Company has you covered. Their donuts are made fresh daily and come in a variety of flavors and styles. From classic glazed to creative specialty donuts, these sugary delights are perfect for starting your day with a smile.

11. Cheesecake Cutie

For dessert lovers, Cheesecake Cutie is a dream come true. Offering a variety of decadent cheesecakes and desserts, this spot is a must-try for anyone with a sweet tooth. Their cheesecakes come in a wide range of flavors, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

12. Hurricane Hanks

Hurricane Hanks is a long-standing favorite on Anna Maria Island. Known for its laid-back atmosphere and delicious food, Hanks offers a mix of American classics and fresh seafood. From grouper sandwiches to perfectly cooked steaks, this spot delivers both flavor and island charm.

13. Fifty Three Fifty

If you’re after high-quality, creative cuisine, Fifty Three Fifty is a standout. With an ever-evolving menu that reflects seasonal ingredients and global inspirations, this restaurant offers a unique take on island dining. Think of it as elevated comfort food with a gourmet twist.

14. Grub AMI

Grub AMI is perfect for those who want a quick yet delicious bite. Their menu focuses on simple, satisfying dishes like burgers, sandwiches, and salads. If you’re craving something fast and tasty, Grub AMI is an excellent choice.

15. Breakfast at Victoria’s

Start your day right with Breakfast at Victoria’s. From classic pancakes and waffles to savory omelets and breakfast burritos, this spot offers a great variety of morning staples. They also have lighter options like yogurt parfaits and fresh fruit for a healthier start.

16. Sophia’s Fine Italian Cuisine

Sophia’s brings authentic Italian flavors to the island with a menu featuring everything from pasta and risotto to wood-fired pizzas and classic Italian desserts. If you’re in the mood for a comforting Italian meal, Sophia’s delivers quality and flavor straight to your door.

17. Double Deez Chicago Style Hotdogs

For a taste of the Windy City, Double Deez offers Chicago-style hotdogs done right. With all the classic toppings and a perfectly steamed bun, these hotdogs are a hit for both kids and adults alike. Pair it with some fries and a soda for a fun, easy meal.

18. City Pier Grill

For a taste of true island flavor, City Pier Grill is an excellent choice. Located right on the historic Anna Maria City Pier, this spot specializes in seafood dishes with a view. Whether you’re craving fish tacos, shrimp baskets, or clam chowder, City Pier Grill brings the best of island dining to your doorstep.

19. Mademoiselle Paris – French Restaurant and Bakery

For a touch of European elegance, Mademoiselle Paris offers authentic French cuisine and baked goods. From fresh croissants and pastries to savory quiches and French onion soup, their menu brings a little bit of Paris to Anna Maria Island.

20. Scott’s Deli

For hearty, freshly-made sandwiches, Scott’s Deli is a local favorite. Whether you’re after a classic turkey club or a creative specialty sandwich, Scott’s offers generous portions and flavors that hit the spot. They also have salads and breakfast options, making it a versatile choice for any meal.

21. Wilder’s Slice of AMI

Last but certainly not least, Wilder’s Slice of AMI offers up some of the best pizza on the island. Their menu includes both traditional and creative pizzas, along with wings, salads, and other casual eats. It’s the perfect spot for a laid-back meal that satisfies everyone in the group.

How to Order with IslandEats AMI

Ordering is as easy as visiting their website or using their user-friendly app. Simply browse the menus of your favorite restaurants, select your items, and place your order. You can track your delivery in real-time, ensuring you know exactly when your food will arrive. They also offer a variety of payment options, making the process as seamless as possible.

Enjoy Island Dining Without the Hassle

Whether you’re planning a cozy night in or want to sample the island’s best bites without the wait, IslandEats AMI offers a convenient solution that lets you focus on what really matters—relaxing and enjoying your time on Anna Maria Island. At AMI Rentals, we’re excited to partner with services like IslandEats AMI to help you make the most of your vacation.

Next time you’re hungry, skip the crowded restaurants and let IslandEats AMI bring the flavors of the island right to your door!